Let's get this out of the way up front: the new Apple TV 4K looks exactly like the last model, and it's a bit faster. But what really stands out is the new Siri remote, which is practically an apology for what came before. Instead of being elegantly thin and easy to lose, it's a bit chunky and easier to hold. Instead of an infuriating touchpad, there's a directional pad that also has touchpad capabilities. The new Siri remote is so good, I'd recommend that existing Apple TV 4K owners just buy it separately for $60 and skip the new box entirely.

Gallery: Apple TV 4K (2021) | 7 Photos

/7

Gallery: Apple TV 4K (2021) | 7 Photos

/7

For everyone else, though, is the revamped Apple TV 4K still worth a hefty premium over far cheaper streaming options? That's where things get complicated. The world of streaming video is a bit different now, compared to 2017 when Apple's last set-top arrived. For one, Apple offers its TV app on televisions, game consoles and even Roku's devices. That gives you full access to your iTunes library and Apple TV+. And if you still need some sort of streaming hardware, you can easily snag Roku's 4K stick with a voice-enabled remote for $40. So why, exactly, would you even think about giving Apple $179 (or $199) for something that hasn't changed much in years?

Apple

TV 4K (2021)

90

SCORE
Engadget
90
Critics - Not yet scored
N/A
Users - Not yet scored
N/A

Pros

  • New Siri Remote is excellent
  • Fast app and streaming performance
  • Solid support for Dolby Vision and Atmos
  • Useful integration with iOS devices
  • HomeKit support is a nice plus

Cons

  • Far more expensive than any other streamer
  • Potential issues with SDR content

It all comes down to just how entrenched you are in Apple's ecosystem. I'll confess: even though I've tested out plenty of streaming boxes over the years, I've always come back to the Apple TV as my primary viewing device. I prefer the slick interface to Roku's dated UI. It had Dolby Vision when most others didn't. And, as an iPhone owner, I love having the ability to quickly AirPlay content, or mirror my screen. (Something that's now available on competing platforms, too.) Apple also won me over with its generous offer to upgrade HD iTunes purchases to 4K — that was particularly useful when Disney finally boosted its films to 4K last year.

The big downside before was the old Siri Remote, which was simply a pain to use. That’s why I’m so impressed by this revamp. The new Siri Remote feels practically anti-Apple. It's taller, thicker and its directional pad hearkens all the way back to the 2010 Apple TV's minimalist clicker. This isn't a company that often goes backwards design-wise. The revised Siri Remote is a sign that Apple that's finally responding to user complaints. Because of its bigger size and slightly curved aluminum case, it actually feels better to hold than the last model, which was just an incredibly thin and fragile rectangle. (Who puts glass on a remote? Only Apple!)

review, siri remote, apple, movies, apple tv, set-top boxes, entertainment, apple tv 4k, 4k, streaming boxes, gear

Devindra Hardawar/Engadget

Based on my experience so far, that heft has also made it harder to lose the Siri Remote in my couch. Though that's definitely no excuse for not including AirTags, or some sort of remote finding feature, despite what one Apple exec thinks. On a brighter note, the revamped directional pad is a dream to use. It's perfect for making fine-tuned selections, like choosing between two movies or episodes listed near each other. But, it's also touch sensitive, allowing you to swipe around freely like on the last remote. And as a nice bonus, you can use the directional ring like a jog dial to scrub backwards and forwards in a video. That's reminiscent of the classic iPod scrollwheel, and it's far more accurate than just swiping left or right.

The layout is also more functional: a back button replaces the confusing "Menu" button, while the home, play/pause and unified volume controls all make a return. There's also a mute button up front, while the Siri voice controls are shoved over to the right side of the remote. That change kept throwing me for a loop at first, but after a few days I appreciated being able to activate voice commands without worrying about hitting any face buttons.

Apple also added a power button up top, allowing you to turn your TV on and off, as well as put the Apple TV to sleep. Unfortunately, since the TV power button relies on infrared, it couldn't actually control my TCL Roku TV, but that's a problem I have with most universal remotes. One other benefit of the new design: you can actually tell which way is up just by holding the remote.

I'd go as far to say that the new Siri Remote is a genuine selling point for the Apple TV. Given that Roku and Amazon haven't really innovated much with their remotes over the years, if you want something that feels new and fresh there aren’t many options. One downside is that you won’t be able to use the new remote as a game controller, as Apple removed the accelerometer and gyroscope. But I honestly can’t imagine actually playing anything using that old clicker.

Internet Explorer Channel Network


LATEST NEWS

NEWS RELATED

A start-up says its voice recognition tech beats Google and Amazon at reducing racial bias

A young woman using voice recognition software on a smartphone.Luis Alvarez | DigitalVision | Getty Images LONDON — A British speech recognition firm says its software performed better than that of major tech companies like Google and Amazon in understanding Black voices. Speechmatics, which is based in Cambridge, England, said…

Read more: A start-up says its voice recognition tech beats Google and Amazon at reducing racial bias

Everything leaving Amazon Prime Video in October

What’s the most valuable part of your Amazon Prime Video subscription? For some users, it’s the ability to get packages within a few days. But movie and TV lovers know that the heart of Prime Video features a wealth of films and shows that can brighten almost anyone’s day. Prime…

Read more: Everything leaving Amazon Prime Video in October

Everything leaving Netflix in November 2021

Even in the face of stiff competition from several major studios, Netflix is still the king of the streamers. Regardless, not even Netflix can keep all of its TV shows and movies, especially when they didn’t create them. Every month, several of these films and television series depart Netflix, and…

Read more: Everything leaving Netflix in November 2021

The best alien movies of all time

Paraphrasing the late Carl Sagan in 1997’s Contact, Jodie Foster’s Eleanor Arroway says if we’re all there is in the universe, “it seems like an awful waste of space.” That is part, at least, of our fascination with the possibility of intelligent life beyond our own somewhere in the stars.…

Read more: The best alien movies of all time

Apple's new $179 AirPods are the best option for most people

Apple AirPodsSource: Apple Apple's new $170 AirPods with Spatial Audio launch this week. I've been testing a pair for several days and I think they're going to be a big hit. AirPods are part of Apple's Wearables, Home and Accessories business which generated $8.7 billion revenue in the June quarter,…

Read more: Apple's new $179 AirPods are the best option for most people

The MacBook Pro delivers everything Apple fans have been asking for

Apple's 14-inch MacBook ProTodd Haselton | CNBC Apple's 14-inch and 16-inch MacBook Pro laptops launch in stores this week. I've been testing the 14-inch model for the past several days. The new MacBook Pros now have a clear focus on design and function. It's a change from 2016 when, in…

Read more: The MacBook Pro delivers everything Apple fans have been asking for

PVR expects theatrical window to return to pre-Covid length by FY23

There are 15 big Bollywood movies waiting to be released in theatres along with 35-40 medium-size films that are in the pipeline. The coronavirus outbreak, which led to cinema halls across the country remaining shut for months on end, has wrought many changes in the film exhibition business in India,…

Read more: PVR expects theatrical window to return to pre-Covid length by FY23

Movie ticket sales have topped 2020's paltry box office, but still trail 2019's haul by 70%

Jeenah Moon | Reuters With just two months before the end of the year, the coronavirus pandemic continues to loom large over the film industry. Ticket sales in 2021 have already outpaced 2020's paltry box office. But sales still lag nearly 70% behind 2019's $11.4 billion haul. As of Sunday, the…

Read more: Movie ticket sales have topped 2020's paltry box office, but still trail 2019's haul by 70%

'Bhavai' film review: Pratik Gandhi of 'Scam 1992' fame will make you shed tears for his Ravan

Snap's woes with Apple privacy changes signal what investors should expect from Facebook and Twitter

Some top WarnerMedia execs never liked the name 'HBO Max' — the Discovery deal will give them a chance to change it

Google slashes service fees in its app store after similar move by Apple

This is the perfect home theater setup for spooky Halloween movies!

Microsoft's new $1,500 folding phone is a huge improvement from last year

Spotify begins allowing more creators to upload podcasts as it continues to embrace video

'Squid Game' has been watched by two-thirds of all Netflix users but hasn't moved the needle on U.S. subscribers

OTHER NEWS